Daniel Handel spent 11 years as a USAID Foreign Service economist, eventually becoming the agency's lead for evaluation. Now the founder and executive director of The New Foreign Assistance, he joins JD to discuss whether USAID deserved to be dismantled and what a more effective foreign aid system could look like.
Daniel makes the case for fundamental reform, explains why economic growth could outperform traditional aid, and shares what he learned from comparing cash transfers with conventional development programs. They also discuss the human cost of USAID's shutdown, Daniel's unexpected journey from atheism to Catholicism, and practical career advice for Christians who want to make a difference through global development.
This episode was recorded on 23 October 2026.
Articles, Scripture, organisations, and other media discussed in this episode
The New Foreign Assistance – Daniel's organisation, advocating for a conservative, pro-assistance approach to reforming US foreign aid, with a focus on economic growth and effectiveness.
Center for Global Development – Daniel references a report identifying longstanding priorities for foreign assistance reform, arguing that previous administrations made insufficient progress.
Millennium Challenge Corporation – Daniel highlights this US government agency as an example of using evidence to identify and address barriers to economic growth.
GiveWell – Daniel discusses an analysis conducted with GiveWell examining how malaria interventions in Uganda could have saved more lives through improved targeting.
GiveDirectly – Daniel describes discovering GiveDirectly's research on unconditional cash transfers and how it inspired his work comparing cash transfers against conventional USAID programmes.
Africa Jobs Fund – Discussed as an example of supporting entrepreneurship and export-oriented businesses that create jobs in developing countries.
Exporters Without Borders – Daniel praises the organisation's work supporting export industries and entrepreneurship.
mPedigree – Daniel mentions a business tackling counterfeit pharmaceuticals through technology that helps consumers verify medicines.
Tony Blair Institute for Global Change – Mentioned by Daniel as a potential career pathway for young professionals interested in international development.
Growth Teams – Recommended as another organisation to explore for opportunities related to economic development.
ODI Fellowship Scheme – Daniel recommends this fellowship, particularly for UK-based listeners interested in working with governments in developing countries.
CGD Europe – Mentioned as another organisation worth exploring for development careers.
Alpha Course – Daniel describes participating in Alpha while living in Sri Lanka, leading to a profound religious experience that convinced him of the truth of Christianity.
Dominican House of Studies – Daniel recounts attending Vespers here in Washington, DC, an experience that renewed his desire for prayer and eventually contributed to his conversion to Catholicism.
C. S. Lewis's writings – Daniel mentions reading C. S. Lewis as part of his journey towards Christian faith.
Mentioned Scripture:
Jonah 1–2, Jonah and the Great Fish – Daniel recalls hearing the story of Jonah as a child at Hebrew school. His disbelief that someone could survive inside a whale contributed to his early rejection of belief in God.
The commandment to love your neighbour – Daniel encourages Christians to hold firmly to their instinct towards self-sacrificial love while remaining flexible about how to put it into practice.
Matthew 22:39: “And the second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’”
Episode Highlights:
On Why Economic Growth Matters
"We're looking for ladders up into the global middle class. And that really only happens through rapid, broad-based economic growth."
On Why Giving Cash Isn't Always Enough
"I'd say first, what can we do to improve the business enabling environments abroad, to get broad private sector growth going? As often said, the best social safety net is a well-paying job. I think that's true in America, I think that's true around the world."
On What Was Wrong With Traditional USAID Programmes
"It spent $3,000 per household to raise their income $150 per year. So you don't have to be some kind of cost-benefit analysis genius to say, I wonder if it would have been better if we had just given them the money."
On Whether Dismantling USAID Was Worth It
"It's a little too soon to know if the benefits of the new system will outweigh that upfront cost. I'm optimistic that they will."
On His Unexpected Conversion to Christianity
"When you've built your whole life around atheism, it is quite shocking at the age of 26 to find out that you might be wrong about the central question of the universe."
On Finding His Way Back to God
"I went to Vespers and all that just came rushing back, that which had been absent for 14 years, the desire to be close to God, to pray, to read theology, to go to church."
On How Christians Can Make the Greatest Difference
"The instinct to love thy neighbor, self-sacrificial love, is obviously what we're all about as Christians. I want you to hold on to that instinct dearly, but hold on lightly at how to apply it."
-
JD (00:01)
Hello everyone. I am here with Daniel Handel, who is a longtime US foreign assistance officer and founder and executive director of the new foreign assistance, which is making waves as a conservative answer to what's been wrong in development and more importantly, what is the path forward and what can be done from here. So, Daniel, thank you so much for coming on.
Daniel (00:25)
Thanks for having me.
JD (00:27)
first I wanna ask you as an expert in development with decades of experience
did USAID deserve to die?
Daniel (00:35)
In so far as death allows for resurrection, then absolutely yes.
JD (00:41)
It's a a very Christian spin to that answer. So I think we have a lot of listeners who are familiar with the downfall, we might say, of USAID. And we've had other podcasts about this with Colin Aitken at at Michael Kramer's lab and then also Sarah at Givewell. But but but Daniel, you have a lot of experience in this. Could you share a little bit more about who you are and what it is you do to impact the world?
Daniel (01:05)
Yeah, sure, absolutely. So I spent eleven years as a USAID Foreign Service economist serving in Nicaragua, Rwanda, and a couple positions back at a headquarters, ending as USAID's lead for evaluation. I then spent four years at a research organization focusing on what works and development, very much in the randomized control trial, cost-effectiveness, evidence world. Then moved over, you'll you'll like this. I took a job at a aid reform group called Unlocked.
Lock 8 in December 2024. I started in February 2025. Those paying attention will note that January 2025 was an interesting moment for foreign assistance. So really threw myself into the moment and just five months ago started the new foreign assistance, where a conservative pro-assistance, pro-reform advocacy group.
JD (02:00)
So you're at the new foreign assistance. What is your goal with the new foreign assistance? What's your big hairy vision for the next five years?
Daniel (02:07)
Yeah, so absolutely. You know, during my my many years at USAID, an immense amount of frustration about how much good was left on the table.
I often say, think what you want about how we got to this reform moment. It's the greatest reform moment ever, and we really want to make the most of it. First and foremost, we want to see a lot more programming focused on private sector economic growth. That is the fundamental foundation and driver of development. And we'd like to see the US government take bigger bets to be more ambitious. I mean, so much of what we saw before was help 10,000 farmers here, 10,000 farmers there be marginally more productive, smallholder farmers.
Farmers, sure, if those are the two states of the world available, it's better to be a more productive smallholder farmer. But we're looking for ladders up into the global middle class. And that really only happens through rapid broad-based economic growth. So that's where we'd like to see the State Department and foreign assistance. You know, the State Department's not the only piece of the foreign assistance puzzle, but it's an important one, and that's where we'd like to see them focus.
JD (03:14)
So I I wanna jump into the issues here because I know some listeners are are thinking, but we had in USAID and especially PepFar some really fantastic programs that calling it smallball is just the wrong way to put it, right? Like, you know, a lot of malaria programs or or HIV retrovirals that have saved by some estimates, millions of lives. These programs were among those that were cut with the USA downfall. What what do you say to this to this kind of objection to what you're saying?
Daniel (03:43)
Yeah, well let's let's just kind of keep a few things straight. Both those programs were good. They've largely continued. But don't forget the E in PEPFAR, which is emergency. Twenty-five years later, if the program hasn't changed, the transition hasn't happened to local governments.
I think that's a problem. Mark Dyball, Ambassador Mike D Mark Dybald, was on Theory of Change another podcast recently and he talked about his own frustration that the transition which they intended to have happen never happened.
On PMI, look, the administration's doing a lot. They're actually engaging with groups like S.C. Johnson. It's a private sector group which has new Millarial technology. And even where PMI worked, we actually did an analysis of PMI's program in Uganda with GiveWell. And that analysis found that if Uganda had targeted their program differently, it could have saved twice as many lives. So even these flagship, quote unquote effective programs, which people support, really had a lot of room for more improvement.
improvement lives left on the table matter morally that and they matter a lot. So that's why we really think this reform movement is apt and overall good news.
JD (04:56)
So what do we need to see changed in global development, in USAID, for us to reach these goals in five years? What what what concretely do you want to see happen?
Daniel (05:08)
Well, if if I may, let me just go back a little bit to make sure people understand what was. So in the old system, at some point you as a health officer, education officer were getting email about how much money you had to spend in the next year. From the moment that your boss at a mission said, Okay, Daniel, JD, go design a new nutrition program. You're looking at a year to up to two years to get that solicitation out.
Maybe another year from when that solicitation goes out to when a winner has been selected, negotiations complete. Maybe another year while that implementer sets up on the ground. So easily three to four years between when a new program was intended to begin and when it actually began. All that time has human consequence. That's time when nothing was happening that could have happened. So remember that that's really what we're starting from and trying to improve. So we're trying to see a few things. We want to see, like I mentioned before,
Much
more of a focused on dramatic, rapid increases in private sector growth. We'd like to see procurement reform, which puts the emphasis on a program accomplishing something. You get paid when you accomplish the goal of the program, not merely for effort. And we like to see that delay, that lag in when money is available to when actual impact on the ground starts to tighten up a lot. All those would be big wins. And so far I'm pretty happy with what I see the State Department doing.
JD (06:30)
Well, couldn't some of these reforms that you've mentioned have been done without the abrupt stop that we saw back in January last year?
Daniel (06:38)
Well I I I don't know, but I what I do know is that it didn't. the Center for Global Development recently pulled up a report, I think, from two thousand twelve, which laid out six priority or areas for reform. Only two of them were done.
I really think that from Rashaw through Mark Green through Samantha Power, we had a pretty good long run at reformist leadership. And what we got was incremental improvement. So I guess I'm not that optimistic that another 14 years of incremental reform to maybe knock out another two of the six priority areas was the way to go. I think fundamental restructuring is probably the right thing. And I am optimistic, at least hopeful, but truly optimistic, that if you look five, ten years from now, more people will have been.
saved, even given a very pessimistic view of the costs of the shutdown, then would have been saved if we simply trundled along with another 14 years of incremental reform.
JD (07:37)
Can you walk me through how it is that private sector partnerships and unlocking growth as opposed to aid, however effective the aid is, really works? Like what is it that the US government, that the that the administration will do to facilitate or catalyze growth in these developing countries?
Daniel (07:57)
Yeah. Well first thing, I'm all for these use the word small ball. I think I think I've used the word small ball. I'm all for PepFAR, I'm all for PMI, ready-to-use therapeutic food. But those are areas where private philanthropy working with nonprofits could could do the work.
We really want the US government to focus where it has a comparative advantage. Where it could do things, the private sector, private philanthropy, even really big private philanthropy, just can't work. And that's in the policy reform world. That's trade and investment treaties. that is in catalyzing investment
Regimes, which are good not just for one or two businesses or a priority sector, but really for all business, all entrepreneurs. That has a couple big benefits. One benefit is that it's very good for the recipient company country, and it's really good for US business. And I think it's right for us to ask that taxpayer money does have some kind of benefit that redounds to the American people. I absolutely do think that doing good by the world.
is part of our reputation, it is part of demonstrating who we are as a society. I th I do think that's a win. But where there's other foreign policy wins, that's important as well. So the kind of programs
JD (09:13)
So, but where's the low-hanging
fruit in terms of policy wins that unlock growth? Right. I think about Land Purchase example of the Ford Foundation in the 1990s, I think, of how through strategic lobbying of key decision makers in Indian government, the Ford Foundation, or perhaps through its research, was able to nudge the government into locking into liberalizing, into being more being more fair trade and and and
And just have better freer policies that unlocks plausibly hundreds of billions, if not a trillion dollars of growth, I think Lant estimates. So that's huge ROI, right? But like where are the where are those opportunities today? Where's the low-hanging fruit?
Daniel (09:55)
Yeah. Well, low hanging fruit. I I don't wanna be naive. All this is very hard work.
It's right to take a portfolio approach. Something's gonna work, some won't. Let me give one example which exists, and one example which we'd like to, which could exist, which we like to see. So the Millennium Challenge Corporation, for those listeners who are not familiar, it is a Bush-era foreign assistance agency set up outside of USAID, and it really focuses exactly on economic growth. Its basic way of working is it uses data to figure out what are countries which are already on the pathway to reform, and then it uses more evidence.
To figure out what are the constraints, what are the binding constraints to growth. So instead of trying to tackle everything which could conceivably move the needle, trying to focus on where the biggest opportunities are to make a difference. And then it works with those countries to make sure they have skin in the game to say, okay, we have identified labor rigidity.
Or some kind of macroprudential policy as the biggest constraint to growth, let's work with you to remove that constraint. So that model is great. I would love to see more economic growth funding going through the Millennium Challenge Corporation. It's there, has a great tracker, very transparent. So that's an example of something that already exists. The type of program, JD, that we'd like to see exist is something like pioneering, subsidizing pioneer firms.
stick with me for for thirty seconds at econ if if I may. a first mover firm, so the the first mer firm to try a new sector in a given economy creates what economists would call positive spillovers. Just think of it like a lot of information to the market about works, what works.
If it's successful, well, it spawns copycat, so it can't fully capture the the the benefits of investment. But if it fails, if that if that entrepreneurial thing that you're trying to do, say in Ghana, doesn't work, well you bear all the costs. So there's a really clear
Role for government to try to help subsidize and encourage the process of economic discovery. What would make that very different than what USA did is it's not, well, people like me sitting around embassies trying to guess what the best sectors are, what the best firms are. It's truly playing a role that only the government could play, and also allowing the market to do what the market does best. So those are the kinds of things that we think the State Department could do and really should do.
JD (12:22)
So are you familiar with Africa Jobs Fund and Ben Hyman's work? What are your thoughts on them? Yeah.
Daniel (12:24)
I absolutely am, yeah, they're great. Yeah.
Yeah, I think they're I think they're doing great work. you know, I know I know they're new, so we'll see how it goes. There's another group, Exporters Without Borders, I want to give a shout-out to. similarly, doing really good work. And the role for the State Department is to help supercharged groups like that rather than the old kind of aid industrial complex, would be a a great move in the right direction.
JD (12:53)
So, my understanding of the theory of change of Africa Jobs Fund, this new catalyzer, if you will, of entrepreneurship, is that they're trying to find people that can start and scale export manufacturing across the developing countries in a way that would further US interests, but really provide jobs. I I heard her put this way: for those of us that are fans of cash transfers because the research says they work, if
Daniel (13:19)
huh.
JD (13:20)
you
Create a company that provides 10,000 jobs, you've essentially permanently provided for 10,000 cash transcers every single year, as long as that company is in business. That's of course like the reverse way of seeing it. I think most of us just think, okay, that's 10,000 jobs. That's a good thing. It's good for everyone in a world where everyone benefits from comparative advantage and trade, right? So in the case of Africa Jobs Fund, how is it that the State Department
Helps them do what they do? Is it more just helping them get past silly bureaucratic barriers? Or like how does the State Department do that?
Daniel (13:57)
Yeah. Well first you're you're speaking to me when you talk about cash. A lot of my career at USAID was trying to set up rigorous studies comparing typical USAID programs to what if we just got ourselves out of the way? So
JD (14:06)
Well let's talk about that in a minute. Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
Daniel (14:09)
so you're you're speaking speaking to my soul here. listen, I I actually don't believe that the State Department is currently helping Africa Jobs Fund, but they could. So to use that pioneer firm idea that I just mentioned.
Would say, listen, Africa Jobs Fund, while you're out there trying to find entrepreneurs, founders, trying to get firms going, we're gonna give you money to help encourage you to spend more time looking for entrepreneurs and firms which are first movers, so or which are really new to a given sector in a given economy.
But what it's not doing is trying to replicate or replace the expertise of the Africa Jobs Fund very close. They're skilled at finding promising firms. That's just something that the bureaucracy is not skilled at. So it'd be providing some money to incentivize incubators, venture capitalists, and such to put more of their time and talent towards this market failure of first mover firms.
JD (15:08)
So I'm curious how the average voter thinks about something like this, right? The US government subsidizing a market failure to help companies be founded abroad. How does this actually help the average American taxpayer?
Daniel (15:22)
Yeah. Well, you know, forever when I joined USAID in the little crest of USAID, it said aid in the national interest. So one way we've always talked about foreign assistance is building up the next generation of American allies and trading partners. So look, the world economy is is integrated. So when there's more business in let's say Africa, that's more opportunities for consumers in America to to buy things and it's more opportunities
for producers in America to sell things. And in the long run, that kind of mutuality, that that integration really is good for good for the American consumer and the American economy.
JD (16:08)
Nice. okay, I I I think that was an excellent answer. I'm looking through the questions here. I'll cut out this gap. but okay, I'll I'll jump in and talking about cash, and I'd love to hear more about
Daniel (16:20)
Sure.
JD (16:21)
that. so so Daniel, you spent much of your aid pioneering this cash benchmarking approach. You ran a study, I believe, in Rwanda that has been widely cited, including by my my f friend Paul Niehaus.
That cash just works by giving people who are living in extreme poverty $500, for instance, works better than almost everything that we try to subject them to, as far as our, you know, our charity programs, our job training programs, right? People just happen to know what to do with cash if they're living at that level of poverty. But walk me through like your journey with cash transfers and also what role you think cash plays in foreign aid today.
Daniel (17:06)
Yeah, well, I was actually just with Paul earlier this week out at UCSD. So he says hello. yeah, let me let me take you back. So I land in Nicaragua. It's my my first post. I'm a newly minted USAID Foreign Service economist. And two things happened in short succession, which were were very influential for me. The first, I think it was like my second week there, I got called into a meeting. Don't know about what.
And they say, Daniel, you're our mission economist. What three crops should we have Nicaraguan farmers grow? I thought, well, hold on, like this is not how economic growth happens, that someone in government decides what sectors should grow. And even if they e yeah, exactly 100%
JD (17:46)
That's central planning, right? Like that's yeah, we tried that, doesn't work.
Daniel (17:50)
tangent planning.
And even if that was your plan, like I just got here, I'm from the suburbs of New Jersey, I had a garden that's as close to farming as I've ever come. If this is our plan, this is not a very good plan. Second thing, a few weeks later, we, the USA Nicaragua, was wrapping up a kind of typical agricultural extension smallholder farmer program. and by its own, its own
program paperwork, it spent $3,000 per household to raise their income $150 per year. So you don't have to be some kind of cost-benefit analysis genius to say, I wonder if it would have been better if we had just given them the money.
Well, my my then girlfriend at the time, who was doing Peace Corps now, and my wife, who I just had lunch with, you know, we used to sit there and talk
JD (18:38)
Congrats. Yeah.
Daniel (18:39)
and say, I wonder, could we just do this experiment? Could we give some cash to people? We said, no, we don't, you know, we we don't have the we don't have the funds to do that of a proper child. Well, fast forward to 2013, I arrive at my second post in Rwanda, and my I remember the moment well. We were literally unpacking our boxes. My wife comes over with her laptop, says, Daniel, you gotta listen to us. And it's a piece on MPR.
on Planet Money, about a nonprofit called Give Directly, which actually tried this, which gave money to people in Kenya and did a really rigorous randomized control trial. And lo and behold, cash has huge effects across a wide variety of the kinds of areas that USA would try to improve: education, health, financial security.
So I go to my boss, I say, Brian, wouldn't it be great to have Give Directly come here and we do some tests against our typical programs? He says, I've also often wondered if it would be better just to beware the money. Go to the mission director, same thing. It then takes two years to get this thing approved. We have to have the mission director go approve Congress. Everyone, senior leadership at USAID has to approve. So it took a long time to get off the ground. but late 2018, the first results came out, cash compared to typical nutrition program.
And cash did a lot. worth noting that several people in the bureaucracy had the attitude, unfortunately, that if your study found there's a problem with our program, it must have been a problem with your study. It can't possibly have been a problem with our program. But to their credit, the senior officials in Trump One, who at the time really had my back and really said, no, it is right for us to ask hard questions about our performance. and we're we're all for it.
So we set up some other studies doing similar work in in other countries, and the rest is history.
JD (20:29)
So is the administration now u using cash benchmarking as a measuring stick for their program effectiveness?
Daniel (20:36)
No, I don't think so. I mean, honestly, they're still in startup mode. I mean, there's it took sixty years to get to the bureaucracy we had. They're, you know, a year and a bit in. so that's still early days. you know, in my conversations with senior officials now at the State Department, they definitely have a strong sense that we weren't getting enough for what we spent. They don't necessarily use terms like cost effectiveness or impact per dollar, but it's absolutely there in their intuition.
So we'll see. It would it would be great for for cash benchmarking to be used as a hurdle rate as some kind of minimum standard. I don't think we're there yet, but I do like the direction they're going in and trying to get more for the amount that we spend.
JD (21:19)
So, Daniel, you're a big believer in cash, giving cash unconditionally, among other common sense development programs. But, you know, Paul estimates in a paper recently, I think it would cost less than a percent of US GDP to provide enough cash transfers to lift everybody out of extreme poverty, right? Less than a percent. Former USAID wasn't even a percent of US budget. So why not just transfer everything to cash? And I guess my question to you is.
Daniel, if you could press a button that would transform all of US foreign assistance into a cash transfer across the world's poorest people, would you push that button?
Daniel (21:57)
I would think about pushing that button and then I wouldn't. I'd say first, what can we do to improve the business enabling environments abroad, to get broad private sector growth going? As often said, the best the best social safety net is a well paying job. I I think that's true in America, I think that's true around the world.
after we've done everything that the US government could reasonably do to improve trade and investment climates abroad for the benefit of the people and for the benefit of America, after that, if there's some residual left over, then yeah, I actually do think some multi-donor cash transfer fund would be a great way to spend money. But look, you know, I started cash benchmarking not presuming that cash was the best bet, not even presuming it was a good bet, but saying before we, the USAID bureaucracy, you know, who were
given money by Congress to to Stewart, but we should just take seriously that, you know, are we doing at least better than just giving away the money? So I I still want to benchmark other things against cash, but sure, certainly when the goal of a program is to leave households with more money, it's gonna be pretty hard to be cash.
JD (23:06)
So Daniel, three years from now, how will we know whether the new system that's being built up in place of USAID is working?
Daniel (23:15)
Yeah. Well I look for a few things. The first thing has already happened, that appropriated money is being spent. That's happened. They they got all the money out the door by September thirtieth, which is US government's fiscal year deadline.
second, I want to see that speed again, that kind of typical three, four-year gap from when money is available to when serious work starts on the ground. We want to see that close to, I don't know, let's say six months or a year. So far, so good. A lot of the programs are with groups who have the ability to get receive that money and start taking action immediately. the administration has put out, I think it's three executive orders on procurement reform for pay for results.
this gets deep into the weeds of bureaucracy, so stick with me. But there's something called the federal acquisition regulations, which aren't binding just on USAID, but on the whole government, how they do procurement, those have been massively stripped back. So a lot of those upfront reforms needed to streamline procurement have already happened. We're actually starting to work with Congress and the administration now.
Hopefully to set up a unit similar to what the Department of War has called the Defense Innovation Unit to make it easier to work with the private sector. So I'd like to see, I can't remember the timeline you said three or four or five years, that those reforms are taking hold and that the time between when there's money available and money's out the door has been quickly dramatically reduced. And also, I feel pretty qualified to say this as the former head of evaluation. USAID really didn't do a lot of evaluating the impact of.
programs where it did that evaluation, it often did it quite poorly. So we just don't really know a lot about the impact of USAID. So I'd like to see in the future much better feedback loops. So we know if programs are working, then obviously that's important so that you pivot when you find out that a program isn't working. If we do all those things that we see a lot more focusing on these big ticket things which could improve economic growth, I'd feel confident that we've gotten some real reform that's that's taken hold.
JD (25:16)
So, Daniel, I'm gonna push back just one last time on this. So bear with me, because I know
Daniel (25:19)
Go go for it. Yeah.
JD (25:20)
there are listeners who are thinking that you are being way too easy on the administration. That what happened with USAID was an absolute travesty, that plausibly millions of lives were lost in this transition, that a stop button was pressed, that there's no restart button to, that
USAID was already undergoing transitions like this, that they had at its chief economist a a Nobel Prize winner or at least a supporter of Nobel Prize winning research who was already trying to implement all the things you're talking about. So how can you then say, you know, here the devil's advocate here, I'm hearing listener, who wants me to
Daniel (25:58)
Yeah yeah.
JD (25:59)
ask you, how can you then say that things are gonna just proceed in this rosy direction where, you know, US government's gonna make all the right decisions going forward?
Daniel (26:07)
Yeah. Well, I'm gonna say at least few things. I'm from New Jersey, so often when I start, I I keep going. So at least three thoughts here. Thought one. I know Dean Carlin really well. We talk all the time. I'm currently trying to get him to become a Republican, a Catholic, andor a hunter. I think hunting is gonna be the the best bet. He's he's holding tough on on all three.
Dean's a good friend. And Dean did good work. But look, it took to the very end of the Biden administration for the Office of the Chief Economist to get out simply a position paper, not a policy paper, just a position paper, a cost-effectiveness evidence. That says something about the speed of reform when you're the chief economist with very supportive administrator and deputy administrator, if it still takes you years and years just to get out.
A light touch paper saying that USA needs to be thinking about evidence and cost effectiveness, that's a problem. But that is what the speed of reform was. So we really shouldn't be optimistic that just another few years would have led to some kind of transformation to the foreign assistance agency that I think we all want to see. So that's thought one. Thought two on the millions of lives. Look, a lot of smart people have said that the I think you're drawing from this Lancet paper was an overestimate. But just for the sake of argument, JD, let's let's say it's true. Okay. So let's say up front,
Millions of people die. I am not saying that that is what happened, but just for this just for the sake of argument. Okay, so that digs a hole that this reform has to beat. But if over the next few years we could set up, the State Department could set up a system that's much more nimble, much more focused on big-ticket growth, much more focused on working with the private sector on proven solutions. If that saves an extra two, three, four, five million people a year.
Over five, ten years, it may be that many more people are alive than would have been if we had just trundled forth with more incremental reform. So I think it's too early to know if the teardown on net was good or bad. That the lives which could have been saved if USAID had been more effective matter, and they matter morally.
and the gap even between something like a presidential malaria initiative, like the study I mentioned in Uganda, which said twice as many lives could have been saved if USAID Uganda did targeting differently, those matter too. So it's not the case that we had a finely tuned machine which was brought down. We had a particularly not finely tuned machine which is torn down, that tear down, sure, it had a cost, but it's a little too soon to know if the the benefits of the new system will outweigh that upfront cost. I'm optimistic that they will.
JD (28:40)
Thanks, Daniel. So for listeners who want to dig more into these criticisms, you can check out the podcast we did with Colin Aiken and with Sarah. but I think it's good to have both sides of the coin here and to hear Daniel's take. I know you didn't listen to those podcasts, so I'm not expecting you to have spoken explicitly to everything they said or anything, but these are the general some of the general points they raised. Daniel, I'd love to I'd love to ask a little bit more about your personal life and faith before closing with
Daniel (29:05)
Sure.
JD (29:06)
some advice for
Christians who want to have a maximum impact for the world and for the kingdom of God. Sound good?
Daniel (29:12)
Yeah, love it.
JD (29:13)
Awesome. So you didn't make Dean Carlin a Catholic, a Republican, or a Hunter. but are you these things?
Daniel (29:20)
Yeah, yeah, absolutely. So I could I could go in reverse order. I started hunting during during COVID. I was thinking about becoming a vegan, you know. Animals probably don't want to die. You don't strictly need to eat meat to have a healthy diet.
I said, well, if I want to keep eating meat, which was the outcome that I was hoping for of this journey, I said, I think I should hunt. I think I should try, frankly, killing something to try to come face to face with that the animal death implicit in my consumption decisions.
And I found that hunting was spiritually amazing. It is not simply, you know, when you do nature photography, you're going for a hike, you're looking at nature. When you're hunting, you're in nature, you're off trail, you're a predator in the ecosystem. And I found that within me was a deep desire to engage with nature and my own food in that way. I should say I'm still a little ambiguous about the ethics of killing and and eating animals, but I think hunted meat is at least.
the most ethical way to go about eating, these animals have their natural creaturely lives. they often have pretty gruesome deaths. and certainly things like eating venison, eating deer in in the east where there's a lot of overpopulation and they really hurt the environment, I think is is is more ethically responsible than some of the factory farming alternatives. So that's how I became a hunter.
JD (30:50)
What what
do you yeah, what do you think of this eat big animals advice that folks like Bruce Friedrich might say that if you're gonna cause suffering to an animal, you might as well get the biggest bang for your buck. If you're gonna take a life, why not take a big life that can feed a lot of a a lot of mouths, right?
Daniel (31:03)
Yeah, I so I've thought a lot about like I I
think we want to have like the fewest sentient weighted animal deaths. So for example, you might think that a a a mouse and a deer have similar levels of sentience. I I think maybe that's true. Well, certainly there'd be if you have one deer, it would take a lot of mice to equal the meat available in one deer. So I do think if you could eat I mean, whales are pretty smart.
But maybe like a sad whale or certainly an elk or a moose and get as many calories as I think I think that's
JD (31:29)
Like a sad narwhal, yeah. Yeah.
Daniel (31:32)
I think that's the best place to go. And what actually convinced me to to I mean I was easy to convince 'cause I wanted to I didn't want to be vegan is that even
just grain and and vegetable farming leads to animal death. There's runoff, there's pesticides, there's the combine harvester killing, you know, mice and rabbits and and moles and things like that. So I think animals are gonna die for eating. So yes, I think in some in some world, if you can get almost all your calories from eating one large, kind of dumb animal, it's probably the best thing we could do to to minimize animal suffering from our eating.
JD (32:09)
So this isn't an animal welfare podcast, but we've certainly had good episodes on this. I'd love your thoughts on this. Maybe I'll introduce you to Bruce at the conference. who's
Daniel (32:15)
I love it.
JD (32:16)
also a Catholic who's spearheaded a lot of work around around this. But yeah, so Republican and Catholic, maybe you can share with me your your journey towards but towards each of each of these. Yeah.
Daniel (32:28)
Yeah. Well, so let me start with conservatism. You know, I grew up in a a pretty liberal household. My you know, my my dad's a college professor. and I I went to a a northeast liberal school because it was liberal. I I really wanted to be part of kind of a left-wing activist world. I think in college I started
JD (32:48)
What where did you study?
Daniel (32:50)
Brandeis University.
I think pretty early on in my college experience I I noticed that a lot of us kind of repeated let's just call them cultural talking points without a lot of interrogation. And as I kind of went through my college experience, I found myself saying, I wonder, you know, we we to talk about I don't know, the World Bank causing poverty here. Free trade is bad. But actually none of us are economists. I I I wonder if we're getting this right. And the kind of echo chamber kind of bothered me. So I wouldn't say that I I knew that Yeah.
JD (33:16)
Yeah. It bot yeah, they I find that really annoying too. Yeah. Sorry.
Yeah.
Daniel (33:21)
So you I I I
guess at that point I wouldn't say I I thought that conservative ideas were necessarily true. I was just
I was just more curious to hear more perspectives than I than I had. I then went to graduate school at the University of Sussex in England, in the United Kingdom, which at least at the time, this is the early 2000s, was an incredibly left-wing school. I mean, like very anti-American, the economics department, not really, but some of the other departments very anti-Israel, anti-capitalist. and that was really my first exposure to what I would call the the far left. So
At the same time, studying economics and a growing appreciation for the market and entrepreneurship, and then seeing like a really kind of far-left position is probably when I started thinking myself as more more conservative. and then I think you know, fast forward you you go through adulthood, you have kids, you start, I'm a little league assistant baseball coach, I'm involved in my parish community, I have important relationships with my neighbors, and you start to think that actually.
The unit which really matters for human flourishing is much smaller than the US federal government. Certainly my experience at USAID, being a bit disenchanted about the emphasis on central planning, the limits of what government technocracy could accomplish. Kind of were just like, I don't know, nails is a strong word. Tax in the coffin, which over time I kind of looked up and said, actually, I really do identify with what most people would call a conservative worldview. That's my conservatism.
So my religion. I grew up an atheist Jew, so both my parents are are Jewish. I went to Hebrew school. I was bar mitzfud, but all along disbelieving in God.
JD (35:00)
You're in a a a
special place to evangelize Sadine Carlin, right?
Daniel (35:04)
Exactly, exactly, exactly. and I remember that the moment I became an atheist. It was my first day of Hebrew school. We learned about Jonah and the whale. And by a little, I don't know, four or five year old break. There you
JD (35:16)
I re I read it to my son last night. Yep. Yeah.
Daniel (35:18)
go. I I'm like, you can't live inside of a whale.
So I remember my mom came to pick me up from Hebrew school. I had to look up at her. I say, Mom, isn't believing in God a little bit like believing in magic? And she said, like, yeah, I kind of believe that too. So it seems sensible to me. Mom said it's not true, done and dusted. I was an atheist. but I did go through Hebrew school, like, you know, a strong sense of ethnic or cultural Judaism. Went to Brandeis, a predominantly Jewish school.
fast forward to Sussex and the university chaplain there, this is now 2003 when I'm entering grad school, it's a guy named Gavin Ashenden. So Gavin, it was an Anglican at the time, and I I went to him, I I guess just kind of on a whim, just saying, hey, I haven't had a new thought about God since I was five years old.
And here is this person who is a genius. I had just thought that Christians, no offense to Christians out there, were just kind of naive, kind of dumb, that they never stop to think like why do bad things happen to good people or why does God not answer prayer or things like that.
Well, here is someone, Gavin, who is one of the smartest, still is. I've talked to him all the time, one of the smartest people I ever met. So that kind of shook my dismissal of faith. fast forward a few years, I kind of got caught up in grad school and stopped having these conversations with him. I get a job after graduate school in Sri Lanka, did something called the Alpha Course, which maybe some of your listeners are familiar with.
And I had what I interpreted as an amazingly intense experience of the Holy Spirit. I felt that I was held in the presence of God for 20 hours, had a series of mystical experiences which convinced me that Jesus of Nazareth is in fact the Christ, the Son of Living God, and it's right at the middle
JD (37:02)
Hmm. Hmm.
Daniel (37:04)
of this God that I was coming to know.
all this, I should say, was very bad news. When you've built your whole life around atheism, it is quite shocking at the age of 26 to find out that you might be wrong about the central question of the universe. It's a long period of study to try to reconcile and make sense of these experiences. The obvious process of am I insane? What happened? You know, maybe my brain, I have brain cancer. but I I don't know brain cancer. Twenty some odd years later, I'm I'm fine.
and I kind of came to faith through Gavin, through Alpha Court, reading C.S. Lewis, kind of through Anglican channels. And it certainly resonated. The liturgical worship really reminded me of my my Jewish liturgical worship growing up. So I came back to the US, ended up at Anglo-Catholic Church, Ascension in St. Agnes for anybody who's in the DC area. Loved it. It was absolutely high church, very beautiful.
JD (37:54)
Great like high masses, the incense flows. Be I you know,
I bet I've only been there three or four times and I cried at least half the time I was there. Just a beautiful, beautiful liturgy, yeah.
Daniel (38:02)
that's great. Yeah, yeah. It's a wonderful, wonderful church.
I was discerning a call to the to the Anglican priesthood, and then got into USAID and decided, well, I've always this is my secular dream job, let me give it a shot. And so I went abroad and then this this sense, this mystical sense of the presence of God of being transformed inside out just stopped. And over really the next 14 years,
God was just an idea on a shelf. I could look back at my conversion experiences and say, I think that was God. I could still go over like why do I think it's reasonable to take the gospels as a reliable history. but yeah, it just it just seemed like an idea on a shelf. Well, this path.
JD (38:44)
Why do you think that was?
Daniel (38:45)
I don't I you know, I don't I don't know. you know, we often say God's time isn't isn't our time.
I think that's true. I don't have a good sense of what God might have been doing those 14 years. Certainly was giving my me a chance to grow up, to be a professional, to get married, you know, just to have a life, which I certainly you know, I've I've changed a lot over over those years. And then last May, a little bit on a lark, I went to the Dominican House of Studies, which is the Brookland neighborhood of DC. And it's the seminary for the Dominican Order of Catholic priests.
And I went to Vespers and all that just came rushing back, that which had been absent for 14 years, the desire to be close to God, to pray, to read theology, to go to church. and I went outside and one of the friars was out there having a cigarette, which kind of like, I didn't I didn't know these guys smoked. And I said, Listen, can I just talk to you? And we sat and we talked for two hours about the ways that
Anglicanism differs from Catholicism. And I have three really good buddies who were former Anglican priests, including Gavin Ashenden, the chaplain who became a Catholic.
And over the summer of 2025, I spent a lot of time just kind of working out the the theological differences between Anglicanism and Catholicism. And this past Easter has received into the Catholic Church. and now I'm actually teaching at my local parish the the OCIE course. It's the kind of adult conversion course. So, you know, it's not what I expected, but I'm glad I'm here.
JD (40:23)
I'm happy for you, Daniel. You know that what they say the most zealous ones are the converts. So you are you're certainly
Daniel (40:28)
That's right. GL of a convert.
JD (40:29)
lighting the torch for Catholicism here. we've yeah, I I think we've we've had a few Catholics on the podcast, but not as many as we have had Anglicans or Evangelicals. So it sounds like you've made made the journey across all of these camps of the the big
Daniel (40:45)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
JD (40:47)
ten of Christianity that we at Christians for impact try to uphold. So I'm happy for
Yeah.
Daniel (40:54)
Thank you.
JD (40:56)
and I would love to close here the next fifteen minutes or so talking about career advice for Christians who want to tackle especially global poverty and and work potentially in in aid. Daniel, you're an expert in this space, and even more so you you know
How it's changing at a time when it's not really easy from the outside to see what's going on. I love at the New Foreign Assistance website, you have a tracker that is updated with Claude Code of like the biggest updates, not only the news articles you're reading, but the biggest updates in State Department funding. So I recommend listeners or viewers you check that out at the newforignassistance.org. Is that right? and
Daniel (41:37)
That's right. Yeah.
JD (41:38)
but but share with me what's your high level advice for someone who's maybe there's a couple different personas here.
One is the person who's early in their career, they're in their maybe mid-20s, they they want to work in in aid or for the state department. maybe, maybe take that profile. Maybe they have a little bit of experience, they have an education, maybe a master's, but they're just trying to break in at the start of their career. What what would you tell someone in that situation?
Daniel (42:05)
Yeah. Well I have I have some good news and I have some bad news. And it is the same news, which is there's no one way to have a career in in development. You know, when I look around at my colleagues who I really admire, there's no one track. so hop hopefully that feels liberating, but I I do wish there is like just do these three things in order and you're guaranteed to get there. so after that profile, a couple thoughts. The State Department is starting to hire.
money is being spent. It's not as much money as before. More of it, I think, appropriately going through local governments and the private sector, but there's there's still jobs. I would also say some time abroad is super helpful. There's a lot of opportunity if you just go post up and Irobi or or at us. I mean, not everyone obviously has the means and ability to do so. but as more money starts throwing through flowing through host government systems.
There's more of a need for people locally to work to work with government. There's also other programs. There's the Tony Blair Initiative, there's growth teams, there's especially for folks in the UK, the ODI Fellowship, there's lots of different organizations out there.
JD (43:14)
Yeah, please do i include
any UK advice as well, since we have a large UK presence, yes.
Daniel (43:17)
Yep.
there's CGD Europe. So there's a lot of groups out there which are maybe hiring and and looking. if I may riff on my my kind of big push for the private sector, there's huge ecosystems of startups all over Africa and the developing world which need talent. So so please do not think that the only place to have an impact on development is through a four-day bureaucracy. I would encourage you.
not to think that way. Look at opportunities to start a business, to help support a business. there's a lot of not profit
JD (43:49)
Could you give like one or two examples
that you're excited about there? That you would just like it it's not that someone has to found that business, but give an example for the we just had Ben Kolesar who was on the founding team at Wave. it yeah.
Daniel (43:56)
Yeah. Well, so so yeah, absolutely. So first of all, Av
Africa Growth Fund is is a wonderful organization doing good things. There's another group, Pedigree. what they do is there's a big problem with counterfeit drugs in Africa. So they have the ability to track pharmaceuticals, and consumers could use an app to make sure that the drugs that they're buying at at the drugstore are actual drugs, not counterfeit drugs. And
I believe the numbers are astronomical. Like in Nigeria, you know, well over fifty percent of drugs purchased were counterfeit down to, you know, a much, much, much smaller number there. So that's the kind of private sector initiative I think which is great, has a huge human impact, and and could use support.
JD (44:42)
Yeah. Yeah. So I talk to a lot of young professionals who are extremely discouraged right now because it's not obvious who is hiring, where to find jobs. I often point them to the probably good job board or our own job board.
or encourage them to do exactly what you're saying, which is try to be a founding member of a team like Wave in its early days, you know, that is providing real goods and services through a legitimate, you know, company, not on the backs of US, you know, US taxpayer dollars, but like, you know, some sustainable private sector company where they can also learn real world skills that don't just
Daniel (45:19)
Absolutely, yeah.
JD (45:20)
pertain to a specific bureaucracy.
and you know, I think a lot of people find this a lot harder because you have to be a lot more agentic, I would think, to navigate that world. A lot of times you have to go in person, like you said, to see what's happening, what the needs are. I talked with Ben Hyman, who that was actually his top advice from Africa Jobs Fund was like, you know, actually just go and see. A couple Ben Kolesar said this as well. You really need to go and see. it's it's the opposite of a mission trip. You're not
You're not going to serve, you're going to learn. It's an impact trip. You're going to learn what kinds of problems exist so that you can be a part of a solution. but that just requires a level of age agenticness that I think many people who who initially wanted to work in this space maybe are deterred by because it all of a sudden it looks a lot more like entrepreneur like entrepreneurship or or for profit business work, which understandably many people don't want to do.
But maybe need to do. Well what's your advice for the second persona? Here take this second persona. You have somebody that's worked in maybe USAID for a few years, worked in global development for a few years, maybe got laid off in the recent cuts, maybe or maybe they're even working at a nonprofit, and but they're looking for something more, right? Where do they fit in this greater ecosystem? Is it the same thing they should just try their hand at being a part of a for-profit business? Or are there are there specific
Agency like sub agencies or other specific organizations you'd recommend they consider.
Daniel (46:50)
Yeah, well f first you did I I meant to say this before.
I don't for a second, in my optimism about the need for justice reform and the good that could come from this reform moment, mean at all to dismiss the deep human pain for people who got laid off suddenly without warning. Certainly you know, under rhetoric, which was very dismissive about their patriotism and the work that they're doing. my own wife, who is a USA contractor, has had her job slashed dramatically. So I I completely understand the human pain for people who had their careers ripped out from under them.
nothing I I've said should should minimize that fact so I want to be I want to be clear about that. to your to your question I would say look for one good next step.
it's a mistake to think that there's one final destination many years out, whether it's my conversion, becoming a hunter, becoming a a conservative. you know, li life has its twists and turns. All you could do is say one good next step. So I'd encourage people to n to not try to say there's that destination where in the distance I want to get to. Just say what is given the the the the world of opportunities that I'm available, what is one good next step? And you know, even JD looking at your own life.
JD (48:04)
Yeah. 'Cause it it does seem like this
long term planning is impossible if somebody's planning a career in and around the development space with, you know, the turnover of of political power and all the changes happening in the State Department. It does like to me, and I talk to people about this every single week, it does not seem like there's there's somebody that has the answers or that those answers won't, you know, it it seems like those answers will change in even a year or two's time, or could very well change. Right.
Daniel (48:30)
Well, J JD, you
may you may choose to edit this out, but the New Foreign Assistance is still hiring. We're looking for people who take a look at our website, see if you agree with our reform agenda. We're looking for people ideally who who have experience in foreign aid world. And if not, that's okay too. People who would like to spend time with this. So if you are conservative, if you if you think about if you like our reform agenda, please reach out to us. We're we're looking for a few more folks.
JD (48:58)
Very good. Very good. We'll leave that in there. and so are there any outstanding like moonshot opportunities that you'd like to highlight now on the podcast? You have it on your framework on the website, which is great. I loved how you laid it all out there. It was coherent to me. Now you you mentioned, you know, things like
I think it was like neurological development issues. That's my my wife was pregnant two years ago. You know, we had our son, and one of the things we made sure of was that she received enough of a certain nutrient that if she didn't have enough of, it would affect the spinal cord development of our of our child, right? Folic acid,
Daniel (49:34)
Yeah, probably folic acid. Folate.
JD (49:37)
right, right. So, like, you know, that that's a moon like we should be providing the folic acid, because that would like just be good for everyone in the long run, right? Like
Are are what are some of the moonshot opportunities you're really excited about? And presumably there are projects connected to that that people can look into.
Daniel (49:51)
Yeah.
what's the kind of archetype that's out for there is water interventions which are relatively cheap, where there's a known solution, but that solution could be scaled where context doesn't matter that much. Obviously, human physiology varies varies a little bit, but if you're about to get pregnant and you have folic acid,
about ten times out of ten, that'll make a big difference on the on the neurological development of of your baby. so we're looking for interventions where a little bit of money can have a big effect. And that's the kind of thing I it would be great for the State Department to help scale.
So I'm I'm happy, you know, we're still looking for ideas. One of the things I should say, JD, we've just done a lot of work planning here at the New Foreign Assistance, is looking for the other opportunities. So I I would love if your listeners reach out, give us ideas. We're looking for things to pitch to the State Department, like like these moonshots. so I I have some answers, but I I know there's other answers as well and I'm looking to to share ideas.
JD (50:53)
Very good. Any closing career advice for ambitious Christians that want to make the greatest difference they can for the world and for God's kingdom?
Daniel (51:01)
Yeah. So listen, the the the instinct to love thy neighbor, self to self-sacrificial love is obviously what we're all about as Christians. I want you to hold on to that instinct dearly, but hold on lightly at how to apply it. Look, there's a lot of poverty here, there's a lot of poverty in our own communities, a huge amount of action happens at the state level.
most House of Representative offices. they have a limited number of staff. If you go to your local representative and say, is there some kind of volunteer work I could do to help, they'll probably say yes. So there's just so many places to take that love thy neighbor instinct and apply it.
like I said, if you have the ability to go spend some time in a developing country, I am highly, highly confident that you'll find opportunities to use your instinct and your talents for the good of the kingdom of God.
JD (51:57)
Awesome. Daniel, yeah. an anything else you'd like to plug while you're on? So n the new foreign assistance is hiring, check out the website.
Daniel (52:03)
Well, I'd say, JD, this is this is my first
ever podcast interview. So I'm very happy to have
JD (52:09)
Your first ever podcast. Well,
well done, Daniel. Yeah, yeah, excellent excellent excellent conversation.
Daniel (52:14)
Yeah, so thank thank you for giving me the opportunity.
JD (52:18)
Very good. awesome. And if listeners want to get in touch with you, they can do that through your website. Is that right?
Daniel (52:24)
That's right. Daniel at the new foreign assistance dot org. We'd love to hear from you.
JD (52:29)
Awesome. Thanks, Daniel. thank you so much for coming on.
Daniel (52:32)
Thanks, JD. My pleasure.