Daniel Handel: Did USAID Deserve to Die? The Future of Foreign Aid #29

Daniel Handel spent 11 years as a USAID Foreign Service economist, eventually becoming the agency's lead for evaluation. Now the founder and executive director of The New Foreign Assistance, he joins JD to discuss whether USAID deserved to be dismantled and what a more effective foreign aid system could look like.

Daniel makes the case for fundamental reform, explains why economic growth could outperform traditional aid, and shares what he learned from comparing cash transfers with conventional development programs. They also discuss the human cost of USAID's shutdown, Daniel's unexpected journey from atheism to Catholicism, and practical career advice for Christians who want to make a difference through global development.

This episode was recorded on 23 October 2026.

Articles, Scripture, organisations, and other media discussed in this episode

  • The New Foreign Assistance – Daniel's organisation, advocating for a conservative, pro-assistance approach to reforming US foreign aid, with a focus on economic growth and effectiveness.

  • Center for Global Development – Daniel references a report identifying longstanding priorities for foreign assistance reform, arguing that previous administrations made insufficient progress.

  • Millennium Challenge Corporation – Daniel highlights this US government agency as an example of using evidence to identify and address barriers to economic growth.

  • GiveWell – Daniel discusses an analysis conducted with GiveWell examining how malaria interventions in Uganda could have saved more lives through improved targeting.

  • GiveDirectly – Daniel describes discovering GiveDirectly's research on unconditional cash transfers and how it inspired his work comparing cash transfers against conventional USAID programmes.

  • Africa Jobs Fund – Discussed as an example of supporting entrepreneurship and export-oriented businesses that create jobs in developing countries.

  • Exporters Without Borders – Daniel praises the organisation's work supporting export industries and entrepreneurship.

  • mPedigree – Daniel mentions a business tackling counterfeit pharmaceuticals through technology that helps consumers verify medicines.

  • Tony Blair Institute for Global Change – Mentioned by Daniel as a potential career pathway for young professionals interested in international development.

  • Growth Teams – Recommended as another organisation to explore for opportunities related to economic development.

  • ODI Fellowship Scheme – Daniel recommends this fellowship, particularly for UK-based listeners interested in working with governments in developing countries.

  • CGD Europe – Mentioned as another organisation worth exploring for development careers.

  • Alpha Course – Daniel describes participating in Alpha while living in Sri Lanka, leading to a profound religious experience that convinced him of the truth of Christianity.

  • Dominican House of Studies – Daniel recounts attending Vespers here in Washington, DC, an experience that renewed his desire for prayer and eventually contributed to his conversion to Catholicism.

  • C. S. Lewis's writings – Daniel mentions reading C. S. Lewis as part of his journey towards Christian faith.

Mentioned Scripture:

  • Jonah 1–2, Jonah and the Great Fish – Daniel recalls hearing the story of Jonah as a child at Hebrew school. His disbelief that someone could survive inside a whale contributed to his early rejection of belief in God.

  • The commandment to love your neighbour – Daniel encourages Christians to hold firmly to their instinct towards self-sacrificial love while remaining flexible about how to put it into practice.

    • Matthew 22:39: “And the second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’”


Episode Highlights:

On Why Economic Growth Matters

"We're looking for ladders up into the global middle class. And that really only happens through rapid, broad-based economic growth."

On Why Giving Cash Isn't Always Enough

"I'd say first, what can we do to improve the business enabling environments abroad, to get broad private sector growth going? As often said, the best social safety net is a well-paying job. I think that's true in America, I think that's true around the world."

On What Was Wrong With Traditional USAID Programmes

"It spent $3,000 per household to raise their income $150 per year. So you don't have to be some kind of cost-benefit analysis genius to say, I wonder if it would have been better if we had just given them the money."

On Whether Dismantling USAID Was Worth It

"It's a little too soon to know if the benefits of the new system will outweigh that upfront cost. I'm optimistic that they will."

On His Unexpected Conversion to Christianity

"When you've built your whole life around atheism, it is quite shocking at the age of 26 to find out that you might be wrong about the central question of the universe."

On Finding His Way Back to God

"I went to Vespers and all that just came rushing back, that which had been absent for 14 years, the desire to be close to God, to pray, to read theology, to go to church."

On How Christians Can Make the Greatest Difference

"The instinct to love thy neighbor, self-sacrificial love, is obviously what we're all about as Christians. I want you to hold on to that instinct dearly, but hold on lightly at how to apply it."



 

Learn more

 
Next
Next

Noah Maier: What 15 Years of Fundraising Taught Him About Generosity #28